Bellefontaine Homes under $400,000

Bellefontaine Homes under $400,000

Welcome to Bellefontaine, Ohio, a hidden gem nestled in Logan County that perfectly blends small-town charm with modern living. Known for its rich history and vibrant community, Bellefontaine is the perfect place to call home. With a population of just over 13,000 residents, this picturesque city offers a welcoming atmosphere and a strong sense of community spirit.

One of the standout features of Bellefontaine is its stunning natural beauty, with lush parks and scenic landscapes that invite outdoor enthusiasts to explore. The nearby Mad River Mountain offers year-round recreational activities, from skiing in the winter to hiking and biking in the warmer months. The city is also home to several charming boutiques, local eateries, and cultural events that celebrate the region's heritage.

For those seeking affordable housing options, Bellefontaine is a remarkable choice. With a variety of homes available for under $400,000, prospective buyers can find everything from cozy bungalows to spacious family homes. These properties often feature beautiful yards, modern amenities, and the kind of character that makes a house feel like a home. Whether you're a first-time buyer, a growing family, or looking to downsize, Bellefontaine's real estate market offers something for everyone.

Discover the perfect blend of affordability, community, and natural beauty in Bellefontaine. With its welcoming atmosphere and diverse housing options, this charming city may just be the ideal place for you to start your next chapter. Come explore Bellefontaine, where your dream home awaits!

Newest Bellefontaine Homes under $400,000

548 Center Ave, Bellefontaine
$224,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1048947 MLS
This charming two-story property offers approximately 3 bedrooms and 1 full bath, with a versatile layout and a convenient location just minutes from State Route 33. The main floor features a welcoming front room with an open feel leading into the original dining area, a kitchen, laundry area, and a large main-floor bedroom. The second floor offers two additional bedrooms, including a loft-style room with a closet and another private bedroom with its own door and closet. Original character can be found throughout the home, including the covered front porch with classic columns and the home's historic proportions and details. The property also includes a cool, old-fashioned cellar with stone and concrete elements that reflect the age and history of the home. The property is B-1 zoned, offering an interesting opportunity for an entrepreneur, home-office user, professional, or buyer looking for a property with flexibility and visibility. Situated on a corner lot with room for parking and easy access to State Route 33, this property offers a unique combination of historic character, practical space, and potential for the next owner to make it their own.

548 Center Ave, Bellefontaine
645 N Main St, Bellefontaine
$219,900
6 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1048878 MLS
Offering three separate residential units in one convenient Bellefontaine location, 645 N Main Street presents a strong opportunity for an investor looking for established rental income and a versatile unit mix. The property includes 645 N Main, featuring 3 bedrooms and 1 full bath; 645 1/2 N Main, offering 2 bedrooms and 1 full bath; and 643 N Main, featuring 1 bedroom and 1 full bath. With approximately 2,768 square feet of total living area, the property provides three distinct rental units under one ownership. The gross monthly rent is $1,900.00 and each tenant is responsible for their own utilities, helping simplify operating expenses for the property owner. Existing leases provide immediate rental income, while the mix of one-, two-, and three-bedroom units offer flexibility for continued rental use. Situated on approximately 0.27 acres along N Main Street, the property is also conveniently located near revitalized downtown Bellefontaine, giving tenants easy access to local restaurants, shops, entertainment, community events, and other downtown amenities while still enjoying a residential setting. Whether you're an experienced investor looking to add another income-producing property to your portfolio or someone just getting started in real estate investing, 645 N Main Street offers an approachable opportunity with three separate rental units, an established income stream, and a convenient location near downtown Bellefontaine. Book showing today!

645 N Main St, Bellefontaine
824 Ridgeview Dr, Bellefontaine
$280,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1048768 MLS
Welcome to 824 Ridgeview Drive! This turn-key 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath split-level home is nestled in an established Bellefontaine neighborhood, just minutes from Mary Rutan Park. The comfortable layout and inviting feel make this a home you can move right into and enjoy. Thoughtfully updated and well cared for, the flooring was replaced in 2020, interior walls and trim were freshly painted in 2026, along with the deck, railings, shutters, and soffits. The bathroom was remodeled in 2024, kitchen appliances were replaced in 2025, and the garbage disposal and kitchen sink were replaced in 2026. The home also features a 2017 furnace and 2015 water heater. Come take a look and see what makes this one feel like home!

824 Ridgeview Dr, Bellefontaine
913 Rush Ave, Bellefontaine
$189,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1048701 MLS
Updated 1.5 story home a mile from downtown Bellefontaine with the big projects already done. Original hardwood floors run through the living and dining rooms, and the navy wainscoting in the dining room gives it real character. The kitchen has white cabinets, butcher block counters, subway tile backsplash and a breakfast nook. The main floor also has a bedroom, a full bath, and a laundry room with the washer and dryer staying. Two more bedrooms upstairs with fresh carpet and ceiling fans. Sliding doors open to a large deck overlooking a deep, tree-lined backyard. Fresh paint throughout, new siding, attached 1 car garage, front porch and a partial basement for storage. Seller is providing a Home Warranty!

913 Rush Ave, Bellefontaine
609 W Chillicothe Ave, Bellefontaine
$159,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1048697 MLS
Charming bungalow full of character. This 2-bedroom, 1-bath home features beautiful original woodwork, French doors, new carpet, and fresh paint throughout. The home sits on two parcels, giving you some extra space and a nice private setting in the back with a creek. There's room for off-street parking, plus a detached one-car garage for parking or extra storage. Closing and title services provided by First Ohio Title. A cozy home with plenty of character, privacy, and potential!

609 W Chillicothe Ave, Bellefontaine
112 E Spring Ave, Bellefontaine
$244,999
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1048662 MLS
What a Great home and you can be Home for the Holidays with this completely remodeled 3-bedroom, 2-bath home. It offers modern comfort and Major systems have been updated, including a new roof (2024) and new water heater (02/2025), along with a fully serviced furnace and A/C system (2025). Additional updates include a new basement door and the basement has been dry this year as of date of listing. Also a new shed, garbage disposal, and insulated crawlspace water lines. Select blinds and shelving were also installed to enhance functionality.

112 E Spring Ave, Bellefontaine
400 Highview Dr, Bellefontaine
$375,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1048654 MLS
Allow us to open the door to this spacious tri-level home. Located in Highview Estates. Interior features include living room with vaulted ceilings, 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, kitchen, breakfast area. Lower-level family room with fireplace, designated utility room and basement perfect for storage. Outside features include fenced rear yard, front porch and updated deck. Roof replaced in 2024, HVAC system in 2018, Hot Water heater in 2021 and deck replaced in 2018. Listing can be purchased along with MLS # 1048653 ( O Grandview Drive for an additional $90,000)

400 Highview Dr, Bellefontaine
332 White Pines Dr, Bellefontaine
$399,990
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1048640 MLS
Welcome to 332 White Pines Drive in the sought-after Maris Park community of Bellefontaine! This beautifully designed home offers an abundance of living space and thoughtful upgrades throughout. The open-concept floor plan features a spacious great room with a desirable bump-out extension, creating the perfect setting for entertaining, family gatherings, or everyday living. The finished basement adds even more functional space, ideal for a recreation room, home theater, fitness area, playroom, or all of the above. A versatile main-floor study provides excellent flexibility and could easily serve as an additional bedroom, guest room, or home office to fit your needs. The spacious kitchen flows seamlessly into the dining and living areas, creating a welcoming atmosphere for both daily life and hosting guests. Upstairs, you'll find comfortable bedrooms and additional living space, while the finished lower level offers valuable square footage rarely found at this price point. Outside, enjoy the attractive curb appeal and convenient location within one of Bellefontaine's newest and most desirable neighborhoods. With its flexible floor plan, finished basement, expanded living area, and prime Maris Park location, 332 White Pines Drive is a home you won't want to miss!

332 White Pines Dr, Bellefontaine
501 N Madriver St, Bellefontaine
$339,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1048614 MLS
Welcome to 501 N. Mad River Street, where untouched historic beauty, rich woodwork and solid craftsmanship take center stage. Offering more than 2,760 square feet of living space, this grand Bellefontaine residence showcases the quality and architectural detail rarely found in newer homes. Soaring ceilings, beautiful parquet flooring, substantial solid-wood trim and timeless character reflect an era when homes were built with artistry and made to last. The spacious floor plan includes 3-4 bedrooms, with a flexible main-level bedroom option, and two beautifully updated full bathrooms. Modern improvements complement the home's historic charm, including 46 replacement windows, a fully remodeled kitchen, renovated bathrooms, custom blinds, a security camera system and a newly added concrete patio. The full basement with egress access provides generous storage and additional functionality. Outside, you'll find a 35x24 detached two-car garage, two additional storage sheds and inviting space to relax or entertain. Conveniently located with easy access to downtown Bellefontaine's dining, shopping and community amenities, this remarkable home offers the perfect blend of preserved character, enduring craftsmanship and modern comfort. Schedule your private tour and experience its beauty firsthand!

501 N Madriver St, Bellefontaine
516 N Park St, Bellefontaine
$288,500
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1048578 MLS
Looking for a home that's close to everything and full of character? This 4 bedroom, 1.5 bath brick two-story is tucked right in town, just across from Bellefontaine Intermediate School, and within walking distance to the park, city pool, and the hospital. Inside, the home has been well taken care of and is ready to move right in. It's got that solid, classic brick-home feel, with four bedrooms giving everyone room to spread out. The backyard has been turned into a peaceful oasis. Two pergolas covered in flowering vines create the perfect shady spots to hang out, sip your coffee, or fire up the grill, and the large, partially fenced yard gives you plenty of room to spread out. The detached 2-car garage has a bonus area - great for a private home office, workshop, game room, or whatever project you've been wanting space for. Homes with this much charm and this kind of location don't sit around long -come see it for yourself!

516 N Park St, Bellefontaine
533 E Chillicothe Ave, Bellefontaine
$269,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1048502 MLS
Really nice home available, this is a must see! 3 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms, 2078 sq ft, with hardwood floors, 3 car detached garage, fenced in back yard, vaulted ceiling in the upstairs master en suite with walk in closet and claw foot tub and a large family room addition with full downstairs bathroom. Previous owner updated bathroom and kitchen and current owners updated home with reverse osmosis and water softener (2019), Gas water heater (2020), windows in back room and utility room (2021), sliding glass door and screen door (2023), furnace (2024), fence/back yard (2024) and updates to garage roof (2026). If that's not enough, Sellers are offering a 1 year home warranty through America's Preferred Home Warranty for the new owners! Come and schedule your private showing.

533 E Chillicothe Ave, Bellefontaine
713 Cooper Ave, Bellefontaine
$189,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1048380 MLS
Move-In Ready - Completely remodeled in 2026! Beautifully renovated 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom ranch home featuring a spacious kitchen, comfortable living room, large bathroom, and convenient main-level washer and dryer hookups. This home was completely remodeled in 2026 with extensive updates throughout, including: New roof, new siding, new gutters, new drywall, updated kitchen, remodeled bathroom, new flooring, updated plumbing, new 200-amp electrical service, foam insulation in the walls and attic, and much more! Outside, enjoy a rear Trex deck, shed, large backyard, and off-street parking. With all the major updates already completed, this home is truly move-in ready. Keys at closing!

713 Cooper Ave, Bellefontaine
Start Your Search